Ford Mustang Mach-E vs Tesla Model Y
Choosing between the Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y is really a question of total cost, not sticker price. Below we compare both over five years — depreciation, energy, insurance and maintenance — then let you run your own mileage.
2026 Ford Mustang Mach-E
Select RWD
2026 Tesla Model Y
Standard RWD 18-in
| $37,795 | MSRP (base, excl. dest.) | $39,990 |
| 3.2 mi/kWh | Efficiency | 4.1 mi/kWh |
| 260 mi | EPA range | 321 mi |
| $43,910 | 5-yr cost of ownership | $42,467 |
| $0.73 | Cost per mile | $0.71 |
Over five years, the Tesla Model Y is the cheaper to own by about $1,443 on these modeled defaults (12,000 mi/yr). Every figure is an editable estimate — run the calculators with your own mileage, financing and local prices.
Run at 12,000 miles a year for five years, MotorCrunch's ownership model puts the Tesla Model Y at $42,467 all-in against $43,910 for the Ford Mustang Mach-E — a gap of $1,443, about $289 a year. That is close to a wash: your own insurance quotes and annual mileage will move the answer more than the default scenario does.
The biggest line separating them is depreciation: roughly $26,165 for the Mustang Mach-E versus $25,164 for the Model Y over five years. With the same drivetrain type, the spread comes down to depreciation (21% vs 18% a year) and each model's insurance risk factor (1.28× vs 1.30×).
Their stickers sit within about $2,195 of each other, so this one is decided by running costs, not the price tag. Adjust the mileage in the comparator below — the ranking can flip if your driving is far from the 12,000-mile default.
Key assumptions for this page
Modeled figures: values tagged modeled are MotorCrunch modeled estimates — outputs of our own transparent models, not published statistics or quotes. Computed with MotorCrunch's ownership-cost model: compounding depreciation, energy at national average prices, modeled insurance and maintenance baselines. Miles ÷ efficiency × national average energy price (last-known-good published price, see /data-sources). Computed with MotorCrunch's premium-factor model (the same model as the estimator widget) at a default driver profile, using this page's vehicle value. Full method: Methodology.
Data updated: 2026-07-17 — verify before purchase.
Ford Mustang Mach-E vs Tesla Model Y: run the numbers
Cheaper to own over 5 years
Tesla Model Y
by $1,443 — Ford Mustang Mach-E: $43,910 · Tesla Model Y: $42,467
Lower 5-year total cost
🏆 Tesla Model Y
Lower energy cost
🏆 Tesla Model Y
Lower depreciation
🏆 Tesla Model Y
Lower insurance estimate
🏆 Ford Mustang Mach-E
Lower cost per mile
🏆 Tesla Model Y
Baseline 5-year cost breakdown
MSRP + EPA efficiency · USD| Cost | Ford Mustang Mach-E | Tesla Model Y |
|---|---|---|
| Depreciation | $26,165 | $25,164 |
| Energy / fuel | $3,188 | $2,488 |
| Insurance | $10,077 | $10,265 |
| Maintenance | $4,480 | $4,550 |
| 5-year total | $43,910 | $42,467 |
| Cost per mile | $0.73 | $0.71 |
Customize your scenario
The baseline uses each car's MSRP, EPA-rated efficiency and segment-typical depreciation. Change the assumptions below to match how you actually drive — your result may differ from the baseline.
5-year cost by annual mileage
| Miles / year | Ford Mustang Mach-E | Tesla Model Y | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8,000 mi | $42,848 | $41,638 | Model Y |
| 12,000 mi· now | $43,910 | $42,467 | Model Y |
| 15,000 mi | $44,707 | $43,089 | Model Y |
| 20,000 mi | $46,035 | $44,126 | Model Y |
| 30,000 mi | $48,691 | $46,199 | Model Y |
Estimates only, not quotes. Depreciation and maintenance use segment-typical modeled assumptions; insurance is a MotorCrunch modeled estimate for a typical driver profile based on each model's value — not an insurer quote. Verify with dealers and insurers before deciding.
Good to know
Specific, useful answers for this page.
Is the Ford Mustang Mach-E or the Tesla Model Y cheaper to own?＋
Over five years, total ownership cost comes down to depreciation, energy, insurance and maintenance. The breakdown above totals both side by side so you can see the real gap, not just the sticker difference.
What's the biggest cost difference between them?＋
Usually depreciation and insurance dominate. The Mustang Mach-E depreciates faster, while insurance tracks each car's risk factor (Mustang Mach-E: 1.28×, Model Y: 1.30×).
Does the price gap between the Mustang Mach-E and Model Y matter long term?＋
The two start within about $2k of each other, so the sticker is close to a wash and running costs decide it. With similar drivetrains, fuel and maintenance land close, leaving depreciation and insurance as the deciders.